Belli's doubler


Belli's "duplicatore" was the first symmetrical "doubler" with rotating motion. It was described by the Italian scientist Giuseppe Belli in the third volume of his Treatise on Experimental Physics, published in 1838 [1][60], described as a prototype.for a more powerful machine, that Belli had already described in a paper in 1831 [2][p61]. The paper mentions development of these machines for four years, and so, supposing that the paper was prepared by 1830, machines like the "duplicatore" were in development by 1826 (this date is mentioned in some texts [3], but without references). The machine didn't attract much attention initially, but when Lord Kelvin described his "Replenisher" in 1868 [p92], the structure was recognized as essentially the same of Belli's device [4].

Its consists of  two, or more, metal disks L-M mounted on insulating rods and can rotate around the central axle F-H turned by the crank I. While rotating they pass inside the charge collectors A-A', that are metal plates folded in "U" mounted on insulating pillars P-Q. Inside the collectors, the disks touch springs connected to the collectors, and a neutralizer bar s-t fixed in the support u, that is not made of insulating material and so can be considered as grounded. If some charge is present at one of the collectors, when a disk touches the neutralizer inside this collector it receives opposite charge from the neutralizer. Continuing  the rotation, the carrier touches the spring of the other collector, and transfers to it most of its charge by a Faraday "ice-pail" effect, where the charge moves to the external conductor due to the repulsion between equal charges. The disk then touches again the neutralizer, inside the other collector, receiving again opposite charge to the charge just transferred and the charge already present on the collector. This charge is then transferred to the first collector, reinforcing the charge there, and the cycle repeats. If body capacitances are ignored, the disks copy the charge on the collectors when touching the neutralizer, and double the charges on both collectors when touching their springs, twice per turn. In practice the doubling is incomplete, because the collectors have significant body capacitance, the shielding made by the collectors is not perfect, and the disks don't receive a complete inverted copy of the charge on the collectors when touching the neutralizer.

This machine was not the first device producing symmetrical charges. Wilson's machine (1804) could be operated in a similar way, with back-and-forth motion, and Volta, Lichtenberg, and others, had already described how to generate symmetrical charges with the "Electrophorus" much before.

Examples of the original machine are difficult to find. The pictures below show a model with gears for speed multiplication, that is now at Liceo Parini, Milan, that seems to be from Belli's time, and an elaborate machine with four carriers, that is at the Museum of the University of Pavia [5], 

Belli     Belli

Drawings of the machine can be found in several publications, but with few variations. The drawing at the top of the page is from [3], and is a copy with some color added from the picture in Belli's book [1]. This picture is from [4], showing the charge collectors having a "V" shape. The most common picture [p14][4], shows the neutralizer apparently passing behind the right collector, what is incorrect, as it must touch the carriers inside the collectors. This section of the plate in Belli's book [1][5] shows three views of the machine, a detail of a collector spring contact, and other unrelated devices.

Reproduction of Belli's doubler

In November 2012 I built a version of Belli's doubler, shown in the pictures below. I made the collectors and four carriers with 0.5 mm aluminum plate, used acrylic rods in the support of the collectors, and made a central hub of HDPE and acrylic to support the carriers, mounted at the tips of brass rods. I mounted the neutralizer bar on a separate wood support, as in the original machine, but made its brushes touch the rods holding the carriers close to the central hub. The brushes for connections with the collectors I mounted at the edges of the collectors, also touching the supporting rods of the carriers. All the brushes can then be adjusted at their best positions. The brushes were made with nickel-chrome wire wrapped on embroidering lines. In this way they don't break too easily, but may cause some startup difficulty. The collectors measure 15 x 11 cm, separated by 11 cm, and form "Us" with 2.5 cm of aperture. The carriers are 9 cm disks. The crank moving the carriers was mounted on a single support similar to the one in the original machine.

Belli's doubler



The machine works as expected, quickly charging the collectors to about 12 kV, positive and negative, before corona leakage at the edges of the carriers and collectors limits the charging. Little sparks can be seen and heard at the brushes. A first version of the machine was built with the holes holding the carriers at the hub crossing it completely. This caused  sparks at the center hole of the hub. A new hub was made with holes not crossing it completely, what solved the problem. The rods are fixed to the hub by pressure only, and the hub is also fixed over the central acrylic cylinder by pressure. An unexpected effect is that the machine works with one collector grounded, producing greater voltage at the other (~18 kV). The neutralizer then develops a voltage of about half this value. Apparently the MDF board used for base provides enough insulation to keep the neutralizer effectively floating. A consequence of this is that if current is drawn from one collector its voltage quickly drops, while the voltage at the other rises. Significant current can be drawn from just one collector only if the other collector is grounded, or if the neutralizer is grounded. This happens in all electrostatic machines with floating neutralizers. This machine, that turns slowly because there is no pulley system, produces very little current (less than 1 µA). The maximum current can be measured by the time that it takes to charge a Leyden jar of known capacitance to a known voltage, connected to one collector, with the neutralizer grounded and the other collector insulated, with the machine at the maximum voltage.

A similar machine was described by Elster and Geitel in 1885 [6] as a didactic machine, apparently without knowledge of the previous works.

A video of the machine in operation.

Belli's disk machine

The machine described in Belli's 1831 paper [2], the "macchina ad attuazione", shown below is very different, and was not intended for symmetrical operation. It has a glass disk with three insulated metal foil sectors, that can be turned at high speed by a double pulley mechanism. The disk turns inside two open boxes, that work as two Leyden jars, with the external iron box being the outer plate, another inner iron box being the inner plate, and resin insulation separating the inner and outer boxes. The edges of the inner boxes are at some distance inside the outer boxes, so when the two parts are joined the outer conductors are in contact but the inner conductors are insulated. Each box has a contact post in connection with the inner conductor and a single contact with the disk surface, terminating on a light metal brush, both passing through glass tubes. The lower sides of the inner boxes are covered by glass plates, for better insulation. To operate the machine, the boxes are joined, some charge is put on the inner conductor of one of the boxes (Belli suggests just touching the internal connector with a silver coin), the disk connection of this box is grounded, and the disk connection of the other box is connected to the corresponding internal conductor connection. The rotation of the disk then charges the sectors by induction, as in the Electrophorus, and transports a current that charges the other box with charge opposite to the charge initially put in the first box, to an amount that is directly proportional to the number of turns. After some turns the connections can be reversed, with the second box being used as inductor and the first as collector, reinforcing the charge on it. When both boxes are well charged, after a few reversals of the connections, a torrent of sparks can be obtained between the two disk contacts, or the machine can be used as a charge source for other objectives, as any electrostatic generator, while the boxes remain charged. Note that the fundamental difference between this machine and the symmetrical doubler is the presence of just two contacts with the rotating disk, that can be used as charge collectors or neutralizers, but not at the same time. The use of the double boxes, forming capacitors and Faraday cages around the disk, is also unusual. At the end of [2] a comment is made about using just two sectors and the addition of a bar that could put them in contact, in fact making it operate as the "duplicatore". The machine in the picture below [5] is in the Museum of the University of Pavia. The drawing is from [2][5].

disk machine


Thanks to Bryan Warner and Paolo Brenni for discussions and materials about these machines.

[1] Giuseppe Belli, "Corso elementare di fisica sperimentale," Vol. III. Società tipografica de' classici italiani, 1838.
[2] G. Belli, "Di una nuova maniera de Macchina elettrica," Annali delle Scienze del Regno Lombardo-Veneto, I, pp. 111-128, 1831.
[3] Giacomo Bruni, "La fisica a Pavia nell '800 e '900: scritti di Giuseppe Belli," Universita degli Studi di Pavia, 1988.
[4] O. Murani, "Il duplicatore del Belli e il replenisher di Lord Kelvin," Il Nuovo Cimento, Serie IV, Tomo I, January 1895, pp. 310-312.
[5] G. Bellodi et al, "La fisica a Pavia nelle opere di Giuseppe Belli," Universitá degli Studi di Pavia, 1994.
[6] J. Elster and H. Geitel, "Notiz über eine Influenzmaschine einfachster Form, " Annalen der Physik, XXV, pp. 493-495, 1885.

Created: 18 December 2012
Last update: 1 January 2013
Developed and maintained by Antonio Carlos M. de Queiroz.

Return to Electrostatic Machines

Lamento informar que o Prof. Antonio Carlos Moreirão de Queiroz faleceu há algum tempo.
Sei que esta página é visitada constantemente. Assim, gostaria de saber se temos algum visitante (interessado) que seja da UFRJ. Se for, por favor, envie um e-mail para
Comento que é impressionante ver o que Moreirão foi capaz de fazer. Ele não só projetou os circuitos, mas também fez todo o trabalho de marceneiro (melhor que muitos que já vi e eram profissionais).
Segundo Moreirão contou em uma palestra, ele só levou choque uma vez. Sem querer encostou o dedo médio em um capacitor com alta tensão que se descarregou através do dedo. A corrente ao passar por uma das articulações a danificou e doía sempre que dobrava esse dedo. Mas, segundo ele, já tinha acostumado.

E. Watanabe (ELEPOT)